Third-party candidates made the difference in 3 states

The Houston Chronicle’s Texas on the Potomac blog gives the vote totals for Indiana, North Carolina, and Missouri. It is obvious that Libertarian Party presidential candidate Bob Barr and Independent presidential candidate Ralph Nader got enough votes to make the difference in those three states between the two major-party candidates. (Constitution Party presidential candidate Chuck Baldwin added to the difference in Indiana.)

What is not provable, however, is how their supporters would have voted if their favorite was not on the ballot. Or, indeed, whether they would have voted at all.

6 Responses to “Third-party candidates made the difference in 3 states”

  1. Michael Seebeck Says:

    Leave it to a blogger in Houston to totally get the vote demographics in Indiana totally wrong. I explained this a month ago.

    I called Indiana for Obama 3 hours before the networks did.

    I did so because Lake County was going 3-1 Obama with only 25% reporting, and at that rate the raw totals would put him over the top. The raw population numbers coupled with the polls closing an hour later in Lake, Porter, and LaPorte counties (my birth area) because of the time zone differences made an Obama victory based on those numbers certain. Barr had nothing to do with it.

  2. steve conn Says:

    This Houston piece is recycled from NPR which treated all third party candidates and independents with contempt and still lost corporate sponsorship and now is forced to cut its staff. Go figure. Ralph Nader’s votes , according to every national poll, may have resulted in a losses to McCain or in no shows or write-ins, but the idea that Obama lost votes is believed only by those who buy into the Carville-Matalin ( she, James Corse’s editor) myth that Nader costy Gore the election in 2000.

  3. Mike Gillis Says:

    I proudly voted for Ralph Nader this year. I couldn’t have voted for any of the other candidates running. Had Nader not run, I would have written in “None of the Above”

  4. Kenny Says:

    I could not vote for any of the candidates this year. Harry Browne would have been my choice in 1996 and 2000. Badnarik was preferable to the rest but I had serious doubts about his candidacy.

  5. DonaldRaymondLake Says:

    In between the kabuki theater we call elections:

    Question: Why Join CRG Network?
    Answer: I’m Upset, Frustrated, and Want Action!
    Every tax-spending special interest group understands the power of solidarity and the strength of numbers. By pooling their votes, money, and other resources they are able to influence lawmakers to trample your rights and funnel tax dollars from YOUR wallet to THEIR pockets - sometimes in the most corrupt ways imaginable.

    Standing alone, fiscal conservatives can never hope to counter this combined might. But, there are still more fiscal conservatives than any other single group. If we unite now, we win! It is that simple. Nothing will change, not taxes, not corruption, not a single thing, until people who care demand it in overwhelming numbers.

    CRG Network is arguably Wisconsin’s most successful fiscally conservative grassroots group. We are about action, not talk and results instead of just promises. We have helped citizens across Wisconsin regain control of government with numerous recalls, election victories, and other strategies to hold fiscally irresponsible and corrupt public officials accountable (both Democrats and Republicans). CLICK HERE to see a list of the many successful actions we have helped citizens accomplish and to learn more about CRG Network.


    Complete the form on the left making certain to fill-in the mandatory fields marked with an asterisk. When finished, click the SUBMIT button. If your selected membership level requires a dues payment it may be paid online by credit card by clicking the PAY DUES ONLINE button and using the PAYPAL system. Checks may be sent to:

    CRG Network
    PO Box 371086
    Milwaukee, WI 53237

    All new memberships come online with At Large privileges (view only) and are upgraded upon receipt of dues.

    There are three levels of membership:

    At Large: At Large membership is free and gives you immediate access to view all the content on this website.

    Associate: Associate membership is $19.00 per year and allows you to access all the interactive portions of the website such as rating politicians, offering comments, and voting on political issues. Your small contribution ensures that CRG Network and this website can continue to operate to the benefit of all.

    Delegate: Delegate membership is the highest level and requires an initial $99 dues payment and $25 per year thereafter. In addition to Associate level privileges, Delegates vote on all political endorsements and campaign contributions and may form and represent new CRG Network Affiliates or serve as the representative to an existing group.

  6. jonathan Says:

    analyzing third party results- updated numbers:

Leave a Reply